The DC Universe is a funny place. Mainly because of its history. You see, the DCU's history has undergone many a reboot and retcon over the decades of its existence. From Crisis on Infinite Earths to Zero Hour to Infinite Crisis, he DCU's history has been rewritten and retconned many times over. But one thing that has never really been explored is the effect it can have on regular people. Imagine having this history of your family been changed and rewritten several times. Relatives being retconned out, then suddenly put back, events being changed. Imagine the effect that would have on you. Well, one young man in the DCU would go through this, and he'd end up crossing paths with a Kryptonian and an empath. This is The Brave and the Bold #17!
The cover is a Phil Winslade piece. It depicts Supergirl and Raven over the Golden Gate Bridge, a big head of Zor-El (Kara Zor-El's dad) evilly grinning at her. I have to admit, I'm not overly fond of the logo they gave Raven for this comic.
"Fathers... Part 1: Past Tense"
Writer: Marv Wolfman
Penciler: Phil Winslade
Inker: Phil Winslade
Colorist: Chris Chuckry
Letterer: Unknown
Editor: Unknown
Executive Editor: Dan DiDio
The story begins with...a flashback.
The flashback is of a woman talking to her son. He's curious as to who his father was. She tells him that she is unaware of his identity. She doesn't even remember being pregnant with their son. The next panel, she says he should forget about him. And then she says that he was a hero, the greatest of them all.
If you're confused by this, trust me, you are not insane. She is then shown in a coffin, with the lid being closed. We next see Supergirl, aka Kara Zor-El. She is not new to this book, having last appeared in issue #2. She is being haunted by images of her father telling her to find Kal-El (aka Superman)...and kill him. Yeah, there is an explanation for this.
Gladly. In Supergirl #4 (February 2006), after Supergirl was split into a good self and evil self thanks to exposure to Black Kryptonite, the evil Supergirl claimed that she was intended to kill Kal-El. He used a special crystal to alter her personality and give her the persona of an "innocent". And the "innocent" persona became dominant. The two Supergirls would merge back together, but as this story shows, she's a bit shaken up by this. Anyway, she's screaming at him to leave her alone.
This was a horrible dream she was having. She realizes that she needs to talk to someone about this. And since the DC Universe has no equivalent of Doc Samson, she'll have to talk to another superhero. She can't talk to Kal about this, and definitely not Batman. As she brushes her teeth, she's hit with some inspiration. She'll go talk to Nightwing.
We get another flashback, a woman saying that a boy named Jonny's father was handsome, just like him. We then get a look in on Sausalito State University.
![]() |
| "They're also putting LSD in the food court Jello!" |
A young man is holding a protest, screaming that the university is developing weapons with a nuclear reactor right in the campus. Two of the protestors are wondering if this is the right course of action. Maybe they should at least try talking to Dean Wilton about this. The leader refuses, saying she's a pencil pusher. The leader asks Christie if she trusts him now. After all, she has before. And he helps...convince her.
![]() |
| "Wow, that crick in my neck is gone!" |
Yeah, there is something scarier going on here. Dean Wilton explains to the police that the protester's leader is named Jonathan Mitchell. Basically, she tells him something that we already have seen. Detective Hambly's called for a negotiator, and wants everyone to stay cool. After all, panicking could cause further problems right now.
The group of students make their way to a large metal door. Jonathan refuses to give up, using his powers to melt his way through. It clearly takes a toll on him. Another flashback to his mother says we don't talk about his father. Christie tries to get him to stop, but Jonathan refuses. He has a goal, and he has to achieve it. Make things right. Like he would have.
The scene then shifts over to Strages Academy. It's a private school located in San Francisco. It's there we meet another player in this little scenario.
![]() |
| "...you could just say you can't, Raven." |
Rachel Roth, aka Raven. Yeah, she died, spent some time as a golden spirit, and in Teen Titans #10 (June 2004), she was resurrected in the body of a teenaged girl. That was a whole thing.
Supergirl grabs Raven and takes her to the top of the building to talk. She says she went to the empath because Nightwing suggested it, as he saw the two as somewhat alike. It's understandable why he'd think that. Both girls had fathers who saw them as weapons. As instruments of destruction. Raven had been taught to resist Trigon's influence from birth and asks if Supergirl really wants her help. The Maid of Might admits that...yes. Yes, she does. Raven tries to help her meditate, but it doesn't go well.
We get another flashback of Jonathan's mother telling him she doesn't know how he was born as she had not been with a man for ages.
Jonathan and his group continue through the building, the man himself feeling weak and woozy from using too much energy. But they can't stop now. He knows the police are here. He can sense there are at least two dozen cops out there. And all of them are fully armed. Hank asks how he knows that, but we can assume that this is part of his power set. Christie advises that Jonathan should rest. The young metahuman angrily refuses this, even going as far as grabbing Christie's throat. Hank is able to get him to calm down. A campus guard points his gun at them, telling them their journey is at an end. A smirking Jonathan counters that it is not.
At the Golden Gate Bridge, Supergirl complains that she can't center her mind because she has a million thoughts blazing through her head. Maybe she's not meant to have any peace of mind, being intended as a weapon, after all. Thingis, Raven naturally thinks that's nonsense. After all, Raven was born to be a weapon herself. By Trigon. She was able to overcome it, so can Kara.
We get another flashback, Jonathan's mother saying there were times she thought that her pregnancy was spontaneous. Hambly and some officers make their way into the university and find the security guard, now dead.
Another flashback with Jonny's mom. She tells him his father vanished, and was never seen again.
Hank, another one of Jonny's party, tells him this has gone too far and he's out.
Can't blame him. Jonathan has killed someone. They're likely going to go jail for this. Jonathan threatens him, his hands glowing. Christie also objects, but Jon uses his power to make her compliant again.
Supergirl and Raven end up in Azarath, Raven's birthplace. They meet up with the priests of the goddess Azar, who helped raise Raven and taught her to control her emotions, lest they bring Trigon on the world. They can help Kara, but it's going to hurt.
Back in California, Jonathan reveals that all his life, he's wondered who his father was. Who he is. His mother kept giving contradictory stories about him. He was a lost hero. He was a villain. He didn't exist. It's here that it's revealed that Jonathan Mitchell is the long-lost son of a hero named William MacIntyre, who also was known by another name: Triumph.
First appearing in Justice League America #91 (August 1994), created by Mark Waid, Brian Augustyn, and Howard Porter, he was conceived as a lost founding member of the Justice League, who got wiped from all memory and existence saving the world. The events of Zero Hour brought him back, but he ended up...struggling thanks to being forgotten and being a non-entity. His tendency to treat others as pawns and arrogance would later get him kicked out of the League. Eventually, he'd fall under the spell of an evil genie, get turned into an ice statue, and then get blown up. Of course, nowadays, the canonicity of this is...uncertain.
Anyway, Hambly finds Jonathan hooked up to a machine, his friends standing beside him. They all seem to be in a trance of some kind.
![]() |
| "Sir, we're at a critical point in this experiment. Please calm down." |
Hambly approaches Mitchell, who says hello. And then, with an evil grin and glowing eyes, tells him "Goodbye".
A flashback to his mother, lying in a hospital bed (implying she was dying), saying that all that matters is that he's here, and he's not his father's son.
The glowing Jonathan, standing in around the destroyed room and the dead bodies, proclaims that he is finally his father's son. Over in Azarath, the monks are helping Supergirl meditate. Raven senses the carnage Mitchell caused, and implores the monks to wake her up.
The monks tell her that's an unwise move. If she awakens now, she will never have peace for the rest of her life.
And that is how the story ends.
I did enjoy this story. The contradictory flashbacks of Jonathan's mother regarding his father is something that can only make sense in the DC Universe, again, thanks to its history getting retconned and rebooted several times over. I'm surprised more DC stories haven't explored the idea of people having all these contradictory memories of various versions of their lives. I can imagine that must be confusing and maddening at the same time.
Jonathan Mitchell is a great foil to Supergirl and Raven. Like them, he is haunted by Triumph. But whereas they are haunted by their fathers using them as instruments of their own evil, Mitchell is haunted by the contradictory nature of his existence: a hero turned villain who was erased from existence, restored, and then his history being thrown into uncertainty again thanks to events like Infinite Crisis. Mitchell's darker nature also makes sense when you keep in mind he's the son of Triumph. William MacIntyre was an arrogant man who saw himself as better than everyone else. You can see a bit of that in Jonathan as well. He is truly his father's son: a man who is after something, and is willing to do anything to get it, even put other people's lives in danger to do so.
I do wish that the story did give us a bit more explanation of who Triumph was, though. He's not exactly a famous character, and a bit of a primer would have been handy for new readers. Who knows, maybe the next issue will educate the reader. I would have loved a bit more exploration of Jonathan's mindset as well. I would have liked to have seen how those contradictory memories of his father affected him growing up.
The only other major issue I had with this story is one that's not the comic's fault: it's one of those stories that's better enjoyed collected as part of a trade than on its own. That's part of the nature of an ongoing serialized series. And that's does not mean the comic is bad on its own. Far from it, a good comic can still be enjoyed better as part of a trade.
I also like the art. Phil Winslade's pencils and Chris Chuckry's colors give the story a moody feel, and the flashbacks of Jonathan's mother being in black-and-white is a simple idea, but a very good one. I also think Winslade does some very good facial expressions at times.
If you want to read this tale for yourself, I recommend tracking down the 2009 trade paperback The Brave and the Bold Vol. 4: Without Sin. Thanks for reading this blog entry! If you liked it, show it off! Take care of yourselves and each other! If you like what I write and want to give this blog some additional support, please make a donation to my Ko-Fi! See you next time!
.webp)
















.webp)






















.webp)









