Back in March of 2024, I looked at Batman #452 (Early August 1990), the first part of the Dark Knight, Dark City storyline. Back in 1764, Gotham City was just a mere township. There, a man named Jacob Stockman participated in a ceremony with several other men, including future President Thomas Jefferson. This ceremony involved sacrificing a young woman in an attempt to summon a purportedly bat-like demon called Barbatos. The ceremony was botched. Centuries passed. In the then-modern Gotham City of 1990, strange crimes occurred. A woman dressed as a sphinx jumps off a building. Four babies are kidnapped by the Riddler, who seems to have become much more bloodthirsty than in the past. Batman managed to save one baby, but his quest is only a quarter complete. Where do we go from here? Let's find out in Batman #453!
The cover is a piece.
The story begins with Batman encountering a zombie.
Page 31, Panel 1
It's the DC Universe, Batman encountering a zombie is very plausible. You may want to destroy that thing quick, Bats. One zombie can become a lot of zombies really quick, which is demonstrated by the Dark Knight being attacked by, well...a bunch of zombies. Batman hits one, who then groans. But the groan is not your typical zombie groan, leading the Caped Crusader to wonder if these zombies are real, or just people in costumes. Again, DC Universe, either explanation is plausible.
(I'm just saying)
In a white non-descript van parked near the cemetery, the Riddler is watching this with glee with a couple of his henchmen. One notes the supervillain is acting crazier and is more bloodthirsty than usual. The other wonders if he's having a mid-life crisis. I don't blame him for wondering that. Fighting these zombies allows Batman to discover that some of them are advanced animatronics. One he takes down is no robot, or actual undead, but a man named Jimmy in a costume and makeup. Riddler knows that Batman will try to interrogate Jimmy, so he uses a hidden explosive in the makeup on Jimmy's neck to silence him.
Page 35, Panel 7
One of the henchmen (I'm calling him Ted) is shocked by this, but Riddler just tells him to shut up and drive away, by gunpoint.
Batman gives chase. As they drive away, Ted the henchman notes that the Riddler's been acting crazy ever since he found some old book. The Riddler counters that he's never seen things clearer before now. It's like he has some inner voice guiding him, taking him somewhere...
But that will have to be tabled for now. Batman catches up to the van. The van stops, knocking the Dark Knight off. Ted plans to run the Dark Knight over, but Riddler is suddenly like "NOOOOOOOO" and grabs the wheel, causing the van to swerve away. Batman manages to dodge, but this says a lot to him. The Riddler wants him to live. The Riddler needs Batman alive and presumably in one piece. But why?
That's what Batman is wondering. He returns to the cemetery and finds that indeed, these zombies were all animatronics. The Riddler has indeed seemingly become more of a monster. Batman finds the second abducted baby, thankfully safe and sound.
The Caped Crusader then finds another clue, this one carved on a tombstone.
You'll find another little tot, at the 25th who was shot.
We then get a flashback in the form of more of Jacob Stockman's confessions (from the last issue). According to him, he and the rest of his collaborators in demon-summoning fled that basement, trapping the daemon they possibly summoned and the sacrifice they intended to make thanks to boarding up the door. None of them ever returned to that temple. Stockman sold his farm and fled to Canada. He doesn't know the fates of all his fellow summoners. He does know that one killed themselves, a second died in Saratoga (Presumably a reference to the battles, as this summoning happened in 1764, and those battles were fought in 1777), and as for Thomas Jefferson, well...that's obvious.
The farm would be built over and over again, the temple where the ceremony fading into history. Until now, it seems.
Batman returns to Wayne Manor, his mind puzzling over the Riddler's latest...riddle. He relaxes in a chair and lets himself drift off to the land of sleep. He needs it, considering the day he's had.
Bruce then starts having dreams. Dreams about the death of his parents, the event that transformed Bruce's life and set him on the path to becoming the Batman. It's in the nightmare that gives Bruce his answer. You see, the "25th who was shot"? That's a reference to William McKinley. He was the 25th President of the United States, from 1897 to 1901. He was shot and died from the gangrene thanks to the wounds ending up infected.
Batman has played the events of his parents' death in his mind again and again over the years. Again and again and again and again and again and again...
Right, right. Basically, it's gotten to the point where he remembers every detail of that night. And one of those details was that Bruce and his parents passed through McKinley Street on their way to what would become Crime Alley. A frightening possibility comes to the mind of the World's Greatest Detective: that Riddler knows Batman and Bruce Wayne are the same man.
Elsewhere, Riddler and his boys are preparing some more traps for the Batman. Despite that, the detective has work to do! As the sun rises, Bruce swings towards a bar on McKinley. And it's there, a nasty surprise is waiting for him.
Page 46, Panel 4
The van releases some very angry fighting dogs. The dogs attack the people in the bar. One of the bar patrons is an off-duty GCPD officer, and he shoots one of the dogs. One of the dogs tries to attack Batman, and the Dark Knight is forced to stab it in the heart with a knife. The Dark Knight notices that the bartender is running away. He finds it odd. Why did he give Batman the knife, and why is he running away. The off-duty cop assures Bats that he has the bar covered. With that, the Caped Crusader heads out after the van. He catches up to it, revealing it was rigged with an auto-driving device.
The Riddler taunts the Dark Knight Detective over a radio, saying that a baby's life is at stake. He gives Batman an easy riddle.
I'm just below Hamilton East on Wright. I take the corner on Fourth.
He tells Batman to hurry up, as he gave the baby a ping-pong ball, and babies love putting things in their mouths. That's a normal thing for babies to do, as putting things in their mouths helps babies learn about different tastes and textures. You can learn more here.
Anyway, Batman finds the "just below" part a bit puzzling. What did he mean by that? Is the Riddler being literal, or is it wordplay? The Caped Crusader arrives, then realizes the Riddler may mean the sewers. He hears what sounds like a baby choking, and then a BLINDING LIGHT!
The Riddler's henchmen start beating on Bats, but he quickly gets back his bearings and fights back. The mad puzzle-spreader is like "alright, that's enough". Thankfully, the Dark Knight Detective's guess was dead on.
Page 51, Panel 6
Batman races to the crib. He can deal with his crazed foe later; the baby is more important. There's no time to get the baby to a hospital. Batman tries to pat the baby to get them to spit up the ball, but it's in too deep. And if it's not dislodged in two minutes, the little tyke will choke to death.
Our man's got no choice. He has to perform a tracheotomy. Batman knows how to do one (Because he's Batman. He likely also knows how to do brain surgery), but there's not a lot of time, he's presumably a bit panicked, and also...baby throats are very small. It's very easy to botch this and accidentally kill the little tyke. But there's no options left. The story ends with our man holding up a scalpel from his belt, assuring himself he knows how to do it.
I enjoyed this comic. Dark Knight, Dark City is an underrated storyline, one I think deserves a lot more shout-out and discussion. The idea that Gotham has a dark supernatural taint to it that is one of the reasons why the city seems to be so corrupt and causing insanity is an intriguing one. Yes, I can understand why some would call it a dumb and/or hokey. However, I look at it like this. This is the DC Universe. Batman exists in the same world as Superman. Wonder Woman. Zatanna. It is plausible that Gotham itself has a slight demonic influence. Of course, you don't need to use that to explain all the crime and corruption in Gotham, but I can imagine that not helping things much. And that's scary.
And the cliffhanger is terrifying. Batman is a competent, capable man, but he's still a man. And as I said earlier, it is so easy to botch a tracheotomy, especially on a baby. And considering the state Batman is presumably in at this point: tired, scared...yeah. You really want to read the next issue, hoping that Batman can save this kid.
I also really love the art in this story. It's detailed, expressive, it was a joy to look at.
If you want to read this for yourself, I recommend tracking down the 2015 trade paperback Batman: Dark Knight, Dark City.




























































