It's that time again! It's time to rejoin the First Line as we see their history from their death to their birth. Last time, we saw the Line deal with an old enemy of the Black Fox's, alongside the Mighty Thor, before the humbling he got in the Marvel Age. As we go further back in the Line's history, we end up seeing the First Line, and the United States, suffer a horrific tragedy. You'll see what I mean as we look at Marvel: The Lost Generation #4!
The cover is a John Byrne and Al Milgrom piece. It's pretty neat, if a bit basic. The "main event" of the cover is what appears to be a pair of monsters fighting it out. And we also got members of the First Line staring at this in confusion. I think. I mean, I admit, I'm confused, too. Who are these monsters? Why are they fighting each other? Well, only one way to find out! Read the comic!
"Lightning in The Day"
Writers: Roger Stern and John Byrne
Penciller: John Byrne
Inker: Al Milgrom
Colorist: Glynis Oliver
Letterer: Jack Morelli
Editor: Ralph Macchio
Editor-in-Chief: Bob Harras
The story starts in 1947. A spaceship has crashed on Earth. In particular, the American Southwest. Inside the small ship are a pair of Skrulls.
![]() |
| "Ohh, this is the last time we drink Contraxian ale before flying..." |
Meet Velmax and his commander, Zuhn. You may know Velmax as the First Line member Effigy. But this is some years before he helped found the group, and decades before he'd embrace Earth as his home.
The Skrulls got shot down trying to silence an Earth aircraft that spotted them. When they leave the craft to examine it, Zuhn gets shot by another Terran.
![]() |
| "Holy smokes! ...y'all ain't gonna probe me, are ya?" |
Velmax tries to scare him off by taking the form of a monster. It does work, as the human flees in his truck. Velmax witnesses the man's truck crash into a...rock or something? I don't know. The Skrull soldier goes to investigate and finds the man dead...and based on the smell of alcohol, he was also dead drunk.
Yeah, this is why you don't drink and drive, kids. Especially when you're fleeing from aliens. Velmax learns about the man by checking his wallet. The man served in the Army (presumably during World War II) and was cited for distinguished service. The Skrull then goes to bury him, presumably to help hide any evidence. His name? Jacob "Jake" Scott.
Yeah, there was a "real" Jake Scott. It was not an identity created by Velmax from whole cloth. He literally took the identity of a dead man. But that was in the past.
We next jump ahead to the First Line's base. The time? 10:15 AM, Rocky Mountain Time. The date? November 21, 1963. Nightingale senses that something very bad is about to happen. Beverly, aka Liberty Girl, asks if one of the voices in the healer's head ha4s become precognitive. It's not a premonition or anything like that. It's more like the mysterious healer feels strange resonances, feelings of imminent danger and loss. Basically, this day is giving her a LOT of bad vibes. Gee I wonder why...
Liberty Girl, being the savvy sort here, decides tell "the boys" about this. Who are said "boys"? Why, the Carney Boys, of course! Patrick Carney, the Yankee Clipper, and his younger brother Timothy, aka Kid Justice.
![]() |
| "I am the KING of the pommel horse!" |
Yes, this is a younger Tim, long before he became the more serious Mr. Justice. He's a cocky teenager, thinking he can take on the world. He and Patrick are taking on a training robot created by the Black Fox. The robot is able to toss around Pat, despite his power belt giving him superhuman strength. Tim tries to sneak up on the Fox, but true to the Batman pastiche that he is, he magically saw it coming.
![]() |
| "MY NOSE! MY BEAUTIFUL PERFECT NOSE!" |
It's here that Liberty Girl and Nightingale enter. Black Fox questions Yankee Clipper's decision to make Kid Justice a member of the First Line considering his attitude. But that'll have to be tabled for now. After all, there's some dark clouds coming. It's here we go next to the Northwest Territories of Canada, in particular a Chipewyan reservation outside of Yellowknife. A young man is lifting a large log by himself, showing that his strength matches his size.
![]() |
| 🎵"Doo doo doo, carrying a log, doo doo doo..."🎵 |
Tired of the men's taunts, the powerhouse swings around the big log and slams it on the ground, scaring them off. He the finds himself in the company of Pixie. She's not just impressed by his strength, but the extraordinary self-control he showed with it. She's been watching this man for a few months now, and she believes that he is ready...and she just flies off with him.
![]() |
| "You got nice muscles! PIXIE WANT SNU-SNU!" |
This young man turned out to be one Sam Matonabbe, aka the future Oxbow. Yeah, this is how they met. I am not joking. This is one of the funniest moments of the whole maxiseries.
Meanwhile, back in the First Line's HQ, the team at this time are gathered up (Black Fox, Yankee Clipper, Liberty Girl, Effigy, and Kid Justice) to hear about Nightingale's little bad feeling. She believes some great tragedy will hit within the next 24 hours...in Dallas, Texas.
Yeah, if you're a bit of a history buff like I am, and you've been following this story so far...November 1963? Dallas? Yeah, alarm bells should be going off in your head, too. Effigy puts it together as well.
In Irving, Texas, a man named Lee is preparing a rifle to go hunting. He is caught by a woman named Marina. The two have an argument, and he angrily leaves, slamming the door.
The scene goes to an industrial plant east of Dallas. This plant is part of an aerospace company called Winget. A man named Winget, presumably the head and founder of the company, has hired a man named Luke Garrow for a job. But first, Winget has a special device that he wants to show Mr. Garrow. It's a device that transforms him into a monster.
![]() |
| "I liked this shirt, man!" |
Yup, this man is Howler. You may remember him from issue #6, where he was involved (and seemingly killed) battling the First Line on the Moon in 1969. You may also notice that his fur is white, whereas in his last appearance, it was yellow. Yeah, according to Howler's entry in the Marvel Appendix, this was because Marvel dumped shoddy production on the maxiseries, seeing it likely as an afterthought. I imagine his fur color was changed to yellow to make him more distinct in appearance from the First Liner Yeti, who was a white-furred monster-man himself. From an in-universe perspective, it can be theorized that Garrow regularly used this device after the events of this issue, and it changed his fur's color. That's what the Appendix theorized, and I'll go with it because it does make sense.
Yeah, sorry. Just wanted to give a bit of clarification. Anyway, Winget reveals that much like Mr. Garrow, he himself has the power to change shape. He is a supervillain known as Chimera, and he uses his own shapeshifting power to get one up on his corporate competitors when legit tactics fail. He proposes a partnership, which Garrow is all too happy to agree to.
That night, the two shapeshifters head towards another building. They find a guard sitting at a station. Garrow thinks this will be easy. One guard? Not a problem for a man with his power. He swats the guard away, only to find said guard is a dummy. Not "dummy" as in a stupid person, but a dummy like an actual mannequin. You know, the ones you see in windows of clothing stores.
Turns out the First Line saw this coming and set the two shapeshifters up.
Indeed it is. Chimera is understandably confused and decides, "Welp, time for me to hit the ol' dusty trail!"
During the fight, Black Fox explains that Garrow, being a fugitive wanted in several states (presumably for his activities as Howler), and that's why the First Line is there. He was spotted in the area, and the FBI called the Line in. Chimera realized the FBI are in Dallas because of the President's visit. The Line pursue the green shapeshifter. Liberty Girl tries to lure him in her direction using her cape like a bullfighter. Thing is, she's no Bugs Bunny, and Chimera is no Toro the Bull.
Yeah, that's going to leave a mark. Liberty Girl is badly wounded, Nightingale going to do all they can to save her. Effigy continues the pursuit, wondering if this was the tragedy that the super-healer foresaw. He battles Chimera, the two shapeshifters using their powers to assume a variety of monstrous forms. Effigy is forced to impale Chimera, only to learn something shocking...
![]() |
| "I always knew you'd get me killed one day, Velmax..." |
Yeah, Chimera was Zuhn, Effigy's old commanding officer.
It's here we learn what happened to him after he was shot by the real Jake Scott. Velmax placed the injured Zuhn in a healing pod to keep him safe until it could fix him up from his gunshot wound. But then, the Army showed up. Velmax assumed the form of Jake Scott and gave them a story about evil aliens that he shot, and they dissolved like sugar in coffee. From there, Velmax maintained his cover, using Scott's lack of immediate family and good military record to start a career in politics. It took years, but he eventually got high enough federal clearance to find the craft they crashed to the Earth in.
He had discovered that it had been taken apart and sent to various facilities. Velmax had also discovered that the healing pod that Zuhn was lying in was seemingly destroyed in a lab fire. Zuhn reveals that was obviously not the case. He had managed to get healed up and set that fire deliberately to cover his escape. A dying Zuhn's final question to Velmax is this: Why become Effigy and play superhero with the First Line? What as the point? Velmax tries to explain that he himself is not sure. Perhaps his years of living here has had an effect...
It's at this point that Cassandra Locke arrives. Yeah, remember her? She's been doing a bit of time-jumping throughout this whole thing. She looks in on the First line mourning Liberty Girl. The Yankee Clipper goes to warn her about something, but her time-travel belt reacts to his power belt...
![]() |
| "Oh no, we triggered the Skittle Effect! We're all going to taste the rainbow!" |
Both Cassandra and Patrick Carney vanish, and Nightingale is left rambling about circuits, death...and destiny. Timothy Carney is left confused. Where's Patrick? Is he dead, as well? Thing is, folks...we'll learn where Pat ended up in the future. I promise. Effigy assures the cops and FBI that Chimera won't be a problem ever again, which is true. Unlike many villains who return from the grave in stories, Chimera will stay dead, dead, dead. Forever.
The First Line head back to their headquarters with Liberty Girl's body. Effigy whispers that he never expected her to be their first casualty. Ever the optimist, he Black Fox expected it to be Kid Justice. The two discuss what to tell the press, as they'll be all over this...
...well, except for one thing. The date is November 22nd. The time is 7:50 AM. The man we saw earlier, Lee Harvey Oswald, walks into a Dallas book depository, and his actions will heavily shadow the Line's first major tragedy...
I did enjoy this comic. The theme of tragedy is prevalent in this issue, considering the historical event coming in the foreground, the death of Liberty Girl, and the disappearance of the Yankee Clipper.
Stern and Byrne cleverly used real-life history to pull a tragic twist. We expected the big tragedy to be the First Line failing to prevent the Kennedy assassination, but it tuned out the tragedy was not only the Yankee Clipper vanishing, but Liberty Girl also being the first member of the Line to die in battle.
Yeah, the death of Liberty Girl can be seen as a bit of another "Women in Fridges" moment, much like with Miriam in issue #, but at least Beverly here got to have some dialogue, some interaction with the other First Liners, and also some idea of her personality, if it was just basic stuff. She was a brave and fearless young woman who clearly loved being a hero. I could also imagine that she and Nightingale were friends. So, her death, combined with her encounter with Cassandra Locke in this issue...yeah, it would affect her mentally. We also get the idea that she and the Carney brothers were close, this being the catalyst for Kid Justice to become the more serious Mr. Justice we saw in earlier issues.
Also, I can imagine that some would find it a bit iffy about using the Kennedy assassination as the background to this story. But it does make sense. In general, the Marvel Universe's history is very similar to real world (Issue # not withstanding), so it makes some sense that the Line would have witnessed Kennedy's death. It makes sense they would have tried to prevent it...if they could. This story is clearly an excuse for the Line to not prevent it. Yeah.
My opinion on John Byrne's art here hasn't changed. Still better than the Liefeld imitators.
If you want to read this for yourself, you'll have to find the back issues somewhere. This maxiseries was never collected into a standalone trade. It was collected in a 2018 omnibus: The Marvel Universe by John Byrne, Vol. 2. So, yeah. I would like a trade collection of this maxiseries myself. Thanks for reading this blog entry! If you liked it, show it off! Take care of yourselves and each other! If you like what I write and want to give this blog some additional support, please make a donation to my Ko-fi! See you next time!
.webp)






















.webp)



















.webp)



















